Jon Hamm
Irwin 'Fletch' Fletcher
Roy Wood Jr.
Detective Monroe
Marcia Gay Harden
Countess Sylvia de Grassi
Lucy Punch
Tatiana Tasserly
John Behlmann
Owen Tasserly
Caitlin Zerra Rose
Laurel Goodwin
Gene Amoroso
Pete Who Does the Jumble
Alli Dowling
Baby Charlie
Bates Wilder
Detective #2 / Gruff Cop Over Phone
Erica McDermott
Detective #3
Eugene Mirman
Marv, Yacht Club Security
Kenneth Kimmins
The Commodore
Shawn Fitzgibbon
Countess de Grassi's Driver
Daniel Baek
Neighborhood Man
Thomas Ciarametaro
Horan's Guard #1
Levon Panek
Horan's Guard #2
Eli Neslund
Bart Robinson
Robert Picardo
Count Clementi Arbogastes De Grassi
Marina Re
Italian Housekeeper