John Cusack
George 'Buck' Weaver
Christopher Lloyd
'Sleepy' Bill Burns
Charlie Sheen
Oscar 'Hap' Felsch
D. B. Sweeney
Joseph 'Shoeless Joe' Jackson
Clifton James
Charles 'Commie' Comiskey
Michael Lerner
Arnold Rothstein
John Mahoney
William 'Kid' Gleason
David Strathairn
Eddie Cicotte
Michael Rooker
Arnold 'Chick' Gandil
Don Harvey
Charles 'Swede' Risberg
James Read
Claude 'Lefty' Williams
Jace Alexander
Dickie Kerr
Richard Edson
Billy Maharg
Kevin Tighe
Joseph 'Sport' Sullivan
Michael Mantell
Abe Attell
John Anderson
Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis
Studs Terkel
Hugh Fullerton
Clyde Bassett
Ban Johnson
Barbara Garrick
Helen Weaver
Wendy Makkena
Kate Jackson
Maggie Renzi
Rose Cicotte
Nancy Travis
Lyra Williams
James Desmond
Smitty (as Jim Desmond)
Eliot Asinof
John Heydler
John D. Craig
Rothstein's lawyer
Michael Laskin
Alfred Austrian
Randle Mell
Michael Ahearn
Robert Motz
District Attorney
Matthew Harrington
Writer
Michael L. Harris
Writer (as Michael Harris)
Tom Marshall
Browns umpire
Jack Merrill
Grabiner (as Merrill Holtzman)
Julie Whitney
Woman in Bar
J. Dennis Newman
Reds Player
Charles Siebert
Ivey Wingo (as Charles Siebert II)
Jim Martindale
Cincinnati Umpire
Bill Jennings
Chicago Umpire
Danton Stone
Hired Killer
Patrick Grant
Irish Tenor
Rich Komenich
Jury Foreman
Patrick Brown
New Jersey Fan
John Griesemer
New Jersey Fan
Charles Yankoglu
New Jersey Fan
Michael B. Preston
Ellix (as Michael Preston)