Larry Miller
Inspector Derek Lester
Jay O. Sanders
Samuel Yoder
Michael Lerner
Phil Kleinman
Miguel A. Núñez, Jr.
IRS Insp. Frank Hall
Megan Cavanagh
Levinia Yoder
John Pyper-Ferguson
Henner Lapp
Carrie Preston
Rebecca Yoder
Ethan Phillips
Jerry - Good Guys Realty
John Caponera
Dave - Good Guys Realty
Bobby Steggert
Samuel Yoder Jr.
Michael Angarano
Sammy Yoder
Rosemary Knower
Grandma Yoder
David Harscheid
Grandpa Yoder
June Claman
Judge Joan Northcutt
Crystal Bock
Penny, Brad's Secretary
Monica Deeter
Hannah Yoder
Richard Pelzman
Jonathan Yoder
Terrence Currier
Elder Joseph
Hal Handerson
Elder Thomas
Stefan Aleksander
Jacob Yoder
Holly Atkinson
Bank Teller
Emily Chamberlain
Evelyn, Phil's Secretary
Anthony Azizi
Malik the Cabbie
Drenda Spohnholtz
Waitress
Kirk Alexander
Young Amish Man (uncredited)
Kurt Gerard
Amish Dancer (uncredited)
Natasha Gill
Runway Model (uncredited)
Mandy Kriss
Amish Woman (uncredited)
John Michaelson
Champagne Waiter (uncredited)
Mark Norris
Police Officer (uncredited)
LauraLee O'Shell
New York Socialite (uncredited)
Bryan Spicer
Prisoner (uncredited)
Nick Stellate
Stockbroker (uncredited)
David Scott Taylor
Amish Elder (uncredited)
Tom Templeton
New Yorker (uncredited)