Adam Sandler
Tommy aka White Knife
Steve Buscemi
Doc Griffin
David Spade
General Custer
Nick Nolte
Frank Stockburn
John Turturro
Abner Doubleday
Chris Parnell
Bank Manager
Nick Swardson
Nelly Patch
Norm Macdonald
Nugget Customer
Whitney Cummings
Susannah
Jared Sandler
Babyface Patch
Lavell Crawford
Gus Patch
Blake Clark
Gulch Sheriff
Dan Patrick
Abraham Lincoln
Sarah Minnich
Woman in Bank
Saginaw Grant
Screaming Eagle
Katalina Parrish
Sheriff's Wife
Alex Knight
Ford's Theater Performer #1
Kevin Grady
Nugget Bouncer #1
Catharine E. Jones
Betty Dunson
David Manzanares
Ciciro's Gang
Henry Steckman
Young Tommy
Ruben Rivera Laguna
Young Cicero
Ricardo Andres
Sober Bar Patron (uncredited)
Richard Beal
Town Cowboy (uncredited)
Paul Caster
Angry Townsman (uncredited)
Jetto Dorsainville
Rattlers Gulch Man (uncredited)
Madison Fogle
School Girl (uncredited)
Corinne Fox
Soiled Dove Saloon Girl (uncredited)
Christopher W. Garcia
Towns Boy (uncredited)
Alan Humphrey
Cowboy (uncredited)
Rodger Larance
Townsman (uncredited)
Jameson Macmillan
Cowboy / Townsman (uncredited)
Meggie Maddock
Nugget Prostitute (uncredited)
Natasha Nazario
Nugget Prostitute (uncredited)
Clint Obenchain
Sheriff's Deputy (uncredited)
Martin Palmer
Gambler (uncredited)
Burton Ritchie
Townsman (uncredited)
Gonzalo Robles
Guard (uncredited)
J. Nathan Simmons
Citizen of Rattler's Gulch (uncredited)
Michael E. Stogner
Citizen of Rattler's Gulch (uncredited)
Dana Goodman
Beaver Breath
Jackie Sandler
Never Wears Bra
Chris Kattan
John Wilkes Booth
Tim Herlihy
Nugget Bartender
Sadie Sandler
Dancing Kid #1
Sunny Sandler
Dancing Kid #2
Kenneth Ruthardt
Raging Bear
Jonathan Loughran
Rifleman
King Orba
Nugget Bouncer #2
Ryan Happy
Train Robber #1
Derek Lacasa
Train Robber #2
Tina Parker
Mary Todd Lincoln
Stephen Eiland
Fainting Man
Lauren Poole
Ford's Theater Performer #2
Patrick Gozur
Ford's Theater Performer #3
Fernando Fresquez
Ford's Theater Performer #4
Vanessa Torres
Sexy Bar Girl (uncredited)